How do we rationalize a person's sins being solely their own when we have traditions that blame entire nations for certain acts?Parashat Shemini + ParaThe stoning of Achan's family“Fathers shall not be put to death because of sons, nor shall sons be put to death because of fathers” - Contradiction?Why did God sanction killing everything that breathes against the 7 nations?Why does there seem to be different standards for future sinners?Isn't the concept of mamzerut in violation of Ezekiel 18:19-20?“Fathers shall not be put to death because of sons, nor shall sons be put to death because of fathers” - Contradiction?what is the source that a parent carries the sins of their children when the children are minors?Rambam's seemingly contradictory statements about one who denies the Oral Law
Are Warlocks Arcane or Divine?
Is there a good way to store credentials outside of a password manager?
Meta programming: Declare a new struct on the fly
How can a jailer prevent the Forge Cleric's Artisan's Blessing from being used?
Adding empty element to declared container without declaring type of element
Is there a problem with hiding "forgot password" until it's needed?
Can a Bard use an arcane focus?
In Star Trek IV, why did the Bounty go back to a time when whales were already rare?
Should my PhD thesis be submitted under my legal name?
Does "Dominei" mean something?
Proof of Lemma: Every integer can be written as a product of primes
How to prevent YouTube from showing already watched videos?
My boss asked me to take a one-day class, then signs it up as a day off
Java - What do constructor type arguments mean when placed *before* the type?
Can I rely on these GitHub repository files?
Are taller landing gear bad for aircraft, particulary large airliners?
What (else) happened July 1st 1858 in London?
Stereotypical names
Is it okay / does it make sense for another player to join a running game of Munchkin?
For airliners, what prevents wing strikes on landing in bad weather?
Can somebody explain Brexit in a few child-proof sentences?
How do ultrasonic sensors differentiate between transmitted and received signals?
A known event to a history junkie
Is a naturally all "male" species possible?
How do we rationalize a person's sins being solely their own when we have traditions that blame entire nations for certain acts?
Parashat Shemini + ParaThe stoning of Achan's family“Fathers shall not be put to death because of sons, nor shall sons be put to death because of fathers” - Contradiction?Why did God sanction killing everything that breathes against the 7 nations?Why does there seem to be different standards for future sinners?Isn't the concept of mamzerut in violation of Ezekiel 18:19-20?“Fathers shall not be put to death because of sons, nor shall sons be put to death because of fathers” - Contradiction?what is the source that a parent carries the sins of their children when the children are minors?Rambam's seemingly contradictory statements about one who denies the Oral Law
This is something I always found to be a bit of a contradiction.
The Torah states that a person's sins are their own to bear and that no one may die for the sins of another.
Parents shall not be put to death for children, nor children be put to
death for parents: a person shall be put to death only for his own
crime. - Devarim 24:16
At the same time, we see examples where the Torah cites Hahsem is punishing either entire nations of people or multiple generations of people for a previous wrongdoing.
- The killing of the Egyptian children for the sins of their parents.
- The killing of the Canaanites (including children)
- The killing of the Amalekites (including children)
Cursing multiple generations of those who worship graven images and false gods:
You shall not bow down to them or serve them. For I the LORD your God
am an impassioned God, visiting the guilt of the parents upon the
children, upon the third and upon the fourth generations of those who
reject Me, - Shemot 20:5
Psalms even speaks of it being a blessing to inflict punishments against others in the way they inflicted them upon us.
Fair Babylon, you predator, a blessing on him who repays you in kind
what you have inflicted on us; a blessing on him who seizes your
babies and dashes them against the rocks! - Tehillim 137:8-9
How exactly do we rationalize this with regards to the idea that sins fall upon the individual alone and not their entire community/family/nation?
sin curse contradiction
add a comment |
This is something I always found to be a bit of a contradiction.
The Torah states that a person's sins are their own to bear and that no one may die for the sins of another.
Parents shall not be put to death for children, nor children be put to
death for parents: a person shall be put to death only for his own
crime. - Devarim 24:16
At the same time, we see examples where the Torah cites Hahsem is punishing either entire nations of people or multiple generations of people for a previous wrongdoing.
- The killing of the Egyptian children for the sins of their parents.
- The killing of the Canaanites (including children)
- The killing of the Amalekites (including children)
Cursing multiple generations of those who worship graven images and false gods:
You shall not bow down to them or serve them. For I the LORD your God
am an impassioned God, visiting the guilt of the parents upon the
children, upon the third and upon the fourth generations of those who
reject Me, - Shemot 20:5
Psalms even speaks of it being a blessing to inflict punishments against others in the way they inflicted them upon us.
Fair Babylon, you predator, a blessing on him who repays you in kind
what you have inflicted on us; a blessing on him who seizes your
babies and dashes them against the rocks! - Tehillim 137:8-9
How exactly do we rationalize this with regards to the idea that sins fall upon the individual alone and not their entire community/family/nation?
sin curse contradiction
1
Duplicate? judaism.stackexchange.com/q/83420 judaism.stackexchange.com/q/36478 judaism.stackexchange.com/q/83035
– DonielF
yesterday
Possible duplicate of "Fathers shall not be put to death because of sons, nor shall sons be put to death because of fathers" - Contradiction?
– user15464
3 hours ago
add a comment |
This is something I always found to be a bit of a contradiction.
The Torah states that a person's sins are their own to bear and that no one may die for the sins of another.
Parents shall not be put to death for children, nor children be put to
death for parents: a person shall be put to death only for his own
crime. - Devarim 24:16
At the same time, we see examples where the Torah cites Hahsem is punishing either entire nations of people or multiple generations of people for a previous wrongdoing.
- The killing of the Egyptian children for the sins of their parents.
- The killing of the Canaanites (including children)
- The killing of the Amalekites (including children)
Cursing multiple generations of those who worship graven images and false gods:
You shall not bow down to them or serve them. For I the LORD your God
am an impassioned God, visiting the guilt of the parents upon the
children, upon the third and upon the fourth generations of those who
reject Me, - Shemot 20:5
Psalms even speaks of it being a blessing to inflict punishments against others in the way they inflicted them upon us.
Fair Babylon, you predator, a blessing on him who repays you in kind
what you have inflicted on us; a blessing on him who seizes your
babies and dashes them against the rocks! - Tehillim 137:8-9
How exactly do we rationalize this with regards to the idea that sins fall upon the individual alone and not their entire community/family/nation?
sin curse contradiction
This is something I always found to be a bit of a contradiction.
The Torah states that a person's sins are their own to bear and that no one may die for the sins of another.
Parents shall not be put to death for children, nor children be put to
death for parents: a person shall be put to death only for his own
crime. - Devarim 24:16
At the same time, we see examples where the Torah cites Hahsem is punishing either entire nations of people or multiple generations of people for a previous wrongdoing.
- The killing of the Egyptian children for the sins of their parents.
- The killing of the Canaanites (including children)
- The killing of the Amalekites (including children)
Cursing multiple generations of those who worship graven images and false gods:
You shall not bow down to them or serve them. For I the LORD your God
am an impassioned God, visiting the guilt of the parents upon the
children, upon the third and upon the fourth generations of those who
reject Me, - Shemot 20:5
Psalms even speaks of it being a blessing to inflict punishments against others in the way they inflicted them upon us.
Fair Babylon, you predator, a blessing on him who repays you in kind
what you have inflicted on us; a blessing on him who seizes your
babies and dashes them against the rocks! - Tehillim 137:8-9
How exactly do we rationalize this with regards to the idea that sins fall upon the individual alone and not their entire community/family/nation?
sin curse contradiction
sin curse contradiction
asked yesterday
AvriAvri
1,028112
1,028112
1
Duplicate? judaism.stackexchange.com/q/83420 judaism.stackexchange.com/q/36478 judaism.stackexchange.com/q/83035
– DonielF
yesterday
Possible duplicate of "Fathers shall not be put to death because of sons, nor shall sons be put to death because of fathers" - Contradiction?
– user15464
3 hours ago
add a comment |
1
Duplicate? judaism.stackexchange.com/q/83420 judaism.stackexchange.com/q/36478 judaism.stackexchange.com/q/83035
– DonielF
yesterday
Possible duplicate of "Fathers shall not be put to death because of sons, nor shall sons be put to death because of fathers" - Contradiction?
– user15464
3 hours ago
1
1
Duplicate? judaism.stackexchange.com/q/83420 judaism.stackexchange.com/q/36478 judaism.stackexchange.com/q/83035
– DonielF
yesterday
Duplicate? judaism.stackexchange.com/q/83420 judaism.stackexchange.com/q/36478 judaism.stackexchange.com/q/83035
– DonielF
yesterday
Possible duplicate of "Fathers shall not be put to death because of sons, nor shall sons be put to death because of fathers" - Contradiction?
– user15464
3 hours ago
Possible duplicate of "Fathers shall not be put to death because of sons, nor shall sons be put to death because of fathers" - Contradiction?
– user15464
3 hours ago
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
According to Sanhedrin 27b, children are punished for their fathers’ sins only when they follow in their footsteps; children who do not follow the sins of their fathers are not punished on their account.
ובנים בעון אבות לא והכתיב (שמות לד, ז) פוקד עון אבות על בנים התם כשאוחזין מעשה אבותיהן בידיהן
Are children not punished for their fathers’ sins? But it is written: He remembers the sins of the fathers on the children! That is when they grab hold of the actions of their fathers in their hands.
In all of the examples you brought, the children were just as guilty as the fathers.
Further, Sifri Devarim 280 understands that minors can be punished for their fathers’ sins:
איש בחטאו יומתו. גדולים מתים בעון עצמם, קטנים מתים בעון אבותם.
”Each man for his sin will they die” - Majors die for their own sins, minors die for their fathers’ sins.
Can you explain further why "the children were just as guilty as the fathers" in each case?
– barbecue
yesterday
1
@barbecue The Egyptians tormented the Jews; their children tormented the Jews. The Canaanites were idol worshippers; their children were idol worshippers. Etc. Plus the underage children can be punished even when innocent for their parents’ sins. I think it’s fairly self-explanatory, really.
– DonielF
yesterday
My intention was that you add more detail to your answer to explain WHY the cases are different.
– barbecue
yesterday
add a comment |
Your first quote is only relevant for a Beis Din, for Earthy punishments. One can not offer himself to be stoned instead of his son that sinned, for example.
Traditionally (source needed) the souls are reincarnations of previous souls, bearing their deeds and judgments. Similarly to the 9-dots-4 lines puzzle, as we are unable to solve the justice/injustice paradox within this world (for example why little kids suffer terrible illnesses and death), we have to assume that both souls and judgments extend to the pre-after-world.
Therefore G-d allows himself to judge single people, nations and generations by being able to see the big picture extending the limits of this world.
#1 isn’t necessarily true; see the Gemara I cite in my answer.
– DonielF
yesterday
@DonielF Do you mean "the children were just as guilty as the fathers."? So they are punished on their own - what the big deal?
– Al Berko
yesterday
The problem is that the Gemara applies both Pesukim to the Heavenly courts as well.
– DonielF
yesterday
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
According to Sanhedrin 27b, children are punished for their fathers’ sins only when they follow in their footsteps; children who do not follow the sins of their fathers are not punished on their account.
ובנים בעון אבות לא והכתיב (שמות לד, ז) פוקד עון אבות על בנים התם כשאוחזין מעשה אבותיהן בידיהן
Are children not punished for their fathers’ sins? But it is written: He remembers the sins of the fathers on the children! That is when they grab hold of the actions of their fathers in their hands.
In all of the examples you brought, the children were just as guilty as the fathers.
Further, Sifri Devarim 280 understands that minors can be punished for their fathers’ sins:
איש בחטאו יומתו. גדולים מתים בעון עצמם, קטנים מתים בעון אבותם.
”Each man for his sin will they die” - Majors die for their own sins, minors die for their fathers’ sins.
Can you explain further why "the children were just as guilty as the fathers" in each case?
– barbecue
yesterday
1
@barbecue The Egyptians tormented the Jews; their children tormented the Jews. The Canaanites were idol worshippers; their children were idol worshippers. Etc. Plus the underage children can be punished even when innocent for their parents’ sins. I think it’s fairly self-explanatory, really.
– DonielF
yesterday
My intention was that you add more detail to your answer to explain WHY the cases are different.
– barbecue
yesterday
add a comment |
According to Sanhedrin 27b, children are punished for their fathers’ sins only when they follow in their footsteps; children who do not follow the sins of their fathers are not punished on their account.
ובנים בעון אבות לא והכתיב (שמות לד, ז) פוקד עון אבות על בנים התם כשאוחזין מעשה אבותיהן בידיהן
Are children not punished for their fathers’ sins? But it is written: He remembers the sins of the fathers on the children! That is when they grab hold of the actions of their fathers in their hands.
In all of the examples you brought, the children were just as guilty as the fathers.
Further, Sifri Devarim 280 understands that minors can be punished for their fathers’ sins:
איש בחטאו יומתו. גדולים מתים בעון עצמם, קטנים מתים בעון אבותם.
”Each man for his sin will they die” - Majors die for their own sins, minors die for their fathers’ sins.
Can you explain further why "the children were just as guilty as the fathers" in each case?
– barbecue
yesterday
1
@barbecue The Egyptians tormented the Jews; their children tormented the Jews. The Canaanites were idol worshippers; their children were idol worshippers. Etc. Plus the underage children can be punished even when innocent for their parents’ sins. I think it’s fairly self-explanatory, really.
– DonielF
yesterday
My intention was that you add more detail to your answer to explain WHY the cases are different.
– barbecue
yesterday
add a comment |
According to Sanhedrin 27b, children are punished for their fathers’ sins only when they follow in their footsteps; children who do not follow the sins of their fathers are not punished on their account.
ובנים בעון אבות לא והכתיב (שמות לד, ז) פוקד עון אבות על בנים התם כשאוחזין מעשה אבותיהן בידיהן
Are children not punished for their fathers’ sins? But it is written: He remembers the sins of the fathers on the children! That is when they grab hold of the actions of their fathers in their hands.
In all of the examples you brought, the children were just as guilty as the fathers.
Further, Sifri Devarim 280 understands that minors can be punished for their fathers’ sins:
איש בחטאו יומתו. גדולים מתים בעון עצמם, קטנים מתים בעון אבותם.
”Each man for his sin will they die” - Majors die for their own sins, minors die for their fathers’ sins.
According to Sanhedrin 27b, children are punished for their fathers’ sins only when they follow in their footsteps; children who do not follow the sins of their fathers are not punished on their account.
ובנים בעון אבות לא והכתיב (שמות לד, ז) פוקד עון אבות על בנים התם כשאוחזין מעשה אבותיהן בידיהן
Are children not punished for their fathers’ sins? But it is written: He remembers the sins of the fathers on the children! That is when they grab hold of the actions of their fathers in their hands.
In all of the examples you brought, the children were just as guilty as the fathers.
Further, Sifri Devarim 280 understands that minors can be punished for their fathers’ sins:
איש בחטאו יומתו. גדולים מתים בעון עצמם, קטנים מתים בעון אבותם.
”Each man for his sin will they die” - Majors die for their own sins, minors die for their fathers’ sins.
edited yesterday
answered yesterday
DonielFDonielF
16.2k12584
16.2k12584
Can you explain further why "the children were just as guilty as the fathers" in each case?
– barbecue
yesterday
1
@barbecue The Egyptians tormented the Jews; their children tormented the Jews. The Canaanites were idol worshippers; their children were idol worshippers. Etc. Plus the underage children can be punished even when innocent for their parents’ sins. I think it’s fairly self-explanatory, really.
– DonielF
yesterday
My intention was that you add more detail to your answer to explain WHY the cases are different.
– barbecue
yesterday
add a comment |
Can you explain further why "the children were just as guilty as the fathers" in each case?
– barbecue
yesterday
1
@barbecue The Egyptians tormented the Jews; their children tormented the Jews. The Canaanites were idol worshippers; their children were idol worshippers. Etc. Plus the underage children can be punished even when innocent for their parents’ sins. I think it’s fairly self-explanatory, really.
– DonielF
yesterday
My intention was that you add more detail to your answer to explain WHY the cases are different.
– barbecue
yesterday
Can you explain further why "the children were just as guilty as the fathers" in each case?
– barbecue
yesterday
Can you explain further why "the children were just as guilty as the fathers" in each case?
– barbecue
yesterday
1
1
@barbecue The Egyptians tormented the Jews; their children tormented the Jews. The Canaanites were idol worshippers; their children were idol worshippers. Etc. Plus the underage children can be punished even when innocent for their parents’ sins. I think it’s fairly self-explanatory, really.
– DonielF
yesterday
@barbecue The Egyptians tormented the Jews; their children tormented the Jews. The Canaanites were idol worshippers; their children were idol worshippers. Etc. Plus the underage children can be punished even when innocent for their parents’ sins. I think it’s fairly self-explanatory, really.
– DonielF
yesterday
My intention was that you add more detail to your answer to explain WHY the cases are different.
– barbecue
yesterday
My intention was that you add more detail to your answer to explain WHY the cases are different.
– barbecue
yesterday
add a comment |
Your first quote is only relevant for a Beis Din, for Earthy punishments. One can not offer himself to be stoned instead of his son that sinned, for example.
Traditionally (source needed) the souls are reincarnations of previous souls, bearing their deeds and judgments. Similarly to the 9-dots-4 lines puzzle, as we are unable to solve the justice/injustice paradox within this world (for example why little kids suffer terrible illnesses and death), we have to assume that both souls and judgments extend to the pre-after-world.
Therefore G-d allows himself to judge single people, nations and generations by being able to see the big picture extending the limits of this world.
#1 isn’t necessarily true; see the Gemara I cite in my answer.
– DonielF
yesterday
@DonielF Do you mean "the children were just as guilty as the fathers."? So they are punished on their own - what the big deal?
– Al Berko
yesterday
The problem is that the Gemara applies both Pesukim to the Heavenly courts as well.
– DonielF
yesterday
add a comment |
Your first quote is only relevant for a Beis Din, for Earthy punishments. One can not offer himself to be stoned instead of his son that sinned, for example.
Traditionally (source needed) the souls are reincarnations of previous souls, bearing their deeds and judgments. Similarly to the 9-dots-4 lines puzzle, as we are unable to solve the justice/injustice paradox within this world (for example why little kids suffer terrible illnesses and death), we have to assume that both souls and judgments extend to the pre-after-world.
Therefore G-d allows himself to judge single people, nations and generations by being able to see the big picture extending the limits of this world.
#1 isn’t necessarily true; see the Gemara I cite in my answer.
– DonielF
yesterday
@DonielF Do you mean "the children were just as guilty as the fathers."? So they are punished on their own - what the big deal?
– Al Berko
yesterday
The problem is that the Gemara applies both Pesukim to the Heavenly courts as well.
– DonielF
yesterday
add a comment |
Your first quote is only relevant for a Beis Din, for Earthy punishments. One can not offer himself to be stoned instead of his son that sinned, for example.
Traditionally (source needed) the souls are reincarnations of previous souls, bearing their deeds and judgments. Similarly to the 9-dots-4 lines puzzle, as we are unable to solve the justice/injustice paradox within this world (for example why little kids suffer terrible illnesses and death), we have to assume that both souls and judgments extend to the pre-after-world.
Therefore G-d allows himself to judge single people, nations and generations by being able to see the big picture extending the limits of this world.
Your first quote is only relevant for a Beis Din, for Earthy punishments. One can not offer himself to be stoned instead of his son that sinned, for example.
Traditionally (source needed) the souls are reincarnations of previous souls, bearing their deeds and judgments. Similarly to the 9-dots-4 lines puzzle, as we are unable to solve the justice/injustice paradox within this world (for example why little kids suffer terrible illnesses and death), we have to assume that both souls and judgments extend to the pre-after-world.
Therefore G-d allows himself to judge single people, nations and generations by being able to see the big picture extending the limits of this world.
answered yesterday
Al BerkoAl Berko
6,2701529
6,2701529
#1 isn’t necessarily true; see the Gemara I cite in my answer.
– DonielF
yesterday
@DonielF Do you mean "the children were just as guilty as the fathers."? So they are punished on their own - what the big deal?
– Al Berko
yesterday
The problem is that the Gemara applies both Pesukim to the Heavenly courts as well.
– DonielF
yesterday
add a comment |
#1 isn’t necessarily true; see the Gemara I cite in my answer.
– DonielF
yesterday
@DonielF Do you mean "the children were just as guilty as the fathers."? So they are punished on their own - what the big deal?
– Al Berko
yesterday
The problem is that the Gemara applies both Pesukim to the Heavenly courts as well.
– DonielF
yesterday
#1 isn’t necessarily true; see the Gemara I cite in my answer.
– DonielF
yesterday
#1 isn’t necessarily true; see the Gemara I cite in my answer.
– DonielF
yesterday
@DonielF Do you mean "the children were just as guilty as the fathers."? So they are punished on their own - what the big deal?
– Al Berko
yesterday
@DonielF Do you mean "the children were just as guilty as the fathers."? So they are punished on their own - what the big deal?
– Al Berko
yesterday
The problem is that the Gemara applies both Pesukim to the Heavenly courts as well.
– DonielF
yesterday
The problem is that the Gemara applies both Pesukim to the Heavenly courts as well.
– DonielF
yesterday
add a comment |
1
Duplicate? judaism.stackexchange.com/q/83420 judaism.stackexchange.com/q/36478 judaism.stackexchange.com/q/83035
– DonielF
yesterday
Possible duplicate of "Fathers shall not be put to death because of sons, nor shall sons be put to death because of fathers" - Contradiction?
– user15464
3 hours ago